Guides

Separation anxiety in dogs: signs and what actually helps, from our York trainers

Signs of separation anxiety in dogs, why the usual advice fails, and how structure, rest and training help dogs in East Yorkshire settle when left.

Chico the black German Shepherd lying calmly on a picnic table
Written by
Michael Shepphard
Published
Reading time
4 min

"He's fine when we're in, but the second we leave he howls the house down." We hear a version of this most weeks, often from an owner who's already tried the stuffed Kong, the calming music and the leaving-for-30-seconds-then-coming-back routine, and is now working from the kitchen table because they daren't go out.

Separation anxiety is real and it's miserable for everyone. It's also one of the problems where the standard advice lets owners down, so let's be straight about what tends to work.

What are the signs of separation anxiety?

  • Barking, howling or whining that starts soon after you leave and keeps going.
  • Scratching at doors, chewing door frames, digging at carpets.
  • Toileting indoors when left, from a dog who's otherwise clean.
  • Drooling, panting or pacing before you've even got your shoes on.
  • Following you from room to room and panicking if a door closes between you.

If you're not sure, set your phone up to record the first 20 minutes after you go. What you see will tell you a lot.

Is it separation anxiety or something else?

Not every dog who barks when left has separation anxiety. Some are bored. Some have learned that noise gets the neighbour knocking or you coming back. Some have never been taught how to switch off in the first place, so being left alone just exposes it.

It matters because the fixes are different. A bored dog needs more fulfilment and a job. A dog who's never learned to settle needs structure. A genuinely panicked dog needs all of that plus a careful plan. We work out which one yours is at the first lesson, not from a two-line description.

Why doesn't the usual advice work?

Most of what's online boils down to "leave for one second, come back, leave for two seconds, come back" and "make leaving really positive with a treat". For a lot of dogs it doesn't touch the problem, and here's why.

The dog isn't struggling with the door closing. The dog is struggling because they have no off switch, no experience of being calm on their own, and a day built entirely around you. Working on the doorway without fixing the day underneath is painting over damp.

The other common mistake is well-meaning: letting the dog follow you everywhere, sleep on you, sit on you, be touched constantly. It feels kind. It builds a dog who literally cannot be alone.

What actually helps a dog with separation anxiety?

Rest. Adult dogs need 12 to 14 hours of proper rest a day. Most anxious dogs we meet are getting nowhere near that because they're on high alert all day. A dog who's rested is a dog who can cope.

Crate rest as part of the day, every day. This is the big one. The crate isn't just for when you go out. If the only time your dog is crated is when you leave, the crate becomes the signal that you're leaving, and that makes everything worse. Crate rest happens throughout the day while you're home: an hour mid-morning, an hour in the afternoon, door shut, no fuss. Cue them in and expect them to go in. No coaxing, no treats for going in, and the door opens when they're calm and quiet, not when they whine. Done this way the crate becomes the place they switch off, whether or not you're in the house.

Structure in the home. Place for 20 minutes twice a day during normal family life. Sofa on invitation only. No following you around the house; a house line helps while you teach this. Calm behaviour is what gets attention, freedom and interaction.

Fulfilment with a clear finish. A proper walk, a short structured play session, some training with their food, then rest. A dog who's been fulfilled and then put down to rest settles. A dog who's had a three-mile run and then been left wired doesn't.

Boring departures and arrivals. Leave without a speech. Come home and ignore the dog for a couple of minutes until they're calm, then say hello. It's the opposite of what feels natural, and it works.

Then, and only then, build the time. Once the dog can rest calmly in the crate while you're in the house, being left is a much smaller step.

How long does it take?

It depends on the dog and on how consistently the house runs the plan. Dogs whose owners commit to the structure usually start to change within a few weeks. Severe cases, where the dog is hurting themselves or hasn't been left alone for months, take longer.

When is it a job for us?

If you've read the above and thought "we've tried all that", or if your dog is injuring themselves, destroying the house or you've reached the point where you can't leave at all, get in touch. 1-2-1 lessons are the right starting point for most dogs: we'll assess what's really going on and give you a plan for your home.

For the dogs who are a long way down the road, a residential programme resets the whole routine in a structured environment and hands you back a dog who already knows how to rest. This guide explains how we decide between day training and residential.

Can't leave the house without a guilt trip? Book a free Phone Consultation and we'll talk it through.

Need help with your dog?

1-2-1 Dog Training in York, Pocklington and East Yorkshire, starting with a free phone consultation.

Book your free phone consultation About 1-2-1 training

Questions

Questions about this topic

Can’t see yours? Ask us on a free phone consultation, we reply within 24 hours.

Book your free phone consultation
Should I crate a dog with separation anxiety?

Yes, in most cases, but not only when you go out. Crate rest needs to be part of the day while you're at home too, or the crate just becomes the sign that you're leaving.

Should I get a second dog to keep them company?

Please don't, not for this reason. Most dogs with separation anxiety are attached to people, not dogs, and you risk ending up with two anxious dogs.

Can separation anxiety be cured?

For most dogs it can be reduced to the point where being left a few hours is a non-event. The ones that get there are the ones whose daily structure changes, not just the doorway routine.

Free phone consultation —

Want help with this? Talk to a trainer.

Book your free phone consultation

Pocklington · York · Market Weighton · Seaton Ross · Holme-on-Spalding-Moor · Melbourne · Stamford Bridge · Howden · Selby · Goole · Beverley · Driffield · Hull

Back to top